Diablo 4 is a game that encourages immersion, letting Diablo 4 items players build their characters and make choices that reflect their personality, morality, and motivations. One of the first decisions players face is choosing a sin to inscribe on the Holy Cedar Tablet in Kyovashad. While this choice does not seem to affect gameplay, it has sparked discussions about class alignment, roleplaying implications, and character development.

Does the sin you choose reflect your class? Could it help define your character’s personality? In this blog, we’ll break down how each sin aligns with different Diablo 4 classes, explore the roleplaying impact of the Holy Cedar Tablet, and discuss whether Blizzard could expand on this choice in the future.

The Four Sins & Their Possible Class Connections

The Holy Cedar Tablet presents players with four sins to choose from:

  • Fear
  • Anger
  • Pride
  • Greed

While the choice has no confirmed effect on stats, dialogue, or questlines, players have speculated that certain sins might fit specific classes better. Here’s a breakdown:

1. Fear - The Path of Survival & Caution

Fear is often associated with those who have suffered great loss, experienced trauma, or live in constant anticipation of danger.

Best class match: Necromancer or Rogue

  • Necromancers deal with death and decay, living on the fringes of society. They understand the power of fear—both using it and succumbing to it.
  • Rogues rely on stealth and cunning, and fear can be a driving force behind their survival instincts.

Roleplaying Implications:

  • Your character could be someone who has seen horrors beyond imagining and now treads carefully.
  • Perhaps you were once a soldier who fled a battle and carries that shame.
  • Or maybe you fear losing control to the forces of darkness.

2. Anger - The Drive for Revenge & Power

Anger is a sin fueled by rage, vengeance, and the inability to let go.

Best class match: Barbarian or Druid

  • Barbarians thrive on fury, using their rage to fuel their devastating attacks.
  • Druids, while often viewed as harmonious, also have a connection to nature’s raw power—and can be ruthless when their home is threatened.

Roleplaying Implications:

  • Your character could be a warrior seeking revenge against demons or a personal enemy.
  • Maybe you were wronged by the Cathedral of Light and harbor deep hatred toward them.
  • Anger could drive you to greater strength—or blind you to wisdom.

3. Pride - The Arrogance of Power & Mastery

Pride is a dangerous but seductive sin, often leading individuals to overestimate their abilities or believe they are above others.

Best class match: Sorcerer or Paladin (if introduced in future updates)

  • Sorcerers wield incredible magic, often acting with confidence (or arrogance) due to their raw power.
  • If a Paladin or Templar class ever arrives, they could easily fall into pride, believing their faith makes them untouchable.

Roleplaying Implications:

  • Your character could be a former noble or scholar who believes they are superior.
  • You might see yourself as a chosen one, destined for greatness.
  • Pride could lead to your downfall or redemption, depending on how you play the story.

4. Greed - The Desire for Wealth & Control

Greed is not just about gold—it’s about power, control, and taking more than you need.

Best class match: Rogue or Sorcerer

  • Rogues are natural thieves and assassins, often motivated by personal gain.
  • Sorcerers, though powerful, could see magic as a tool to amass more strength for themselves.

Roleplaying Implications:

  • Your character could be a mercenary, only helping others for the right price.
  • Perhaps you crave legendary artifacts, not caring about the cost.
  • Greed might lead you to betray allies or hoard resources, shaping your interactions with the world.

Does the Holy Cedar Tablet Choice Matter for Roleplaying?

While the Holy Cedar Tablet doesn’t impact gameplay mechanics, it can serve as an important roleplaying tool.

How the Sin Choice Can Define Your Character’s Journey

Even without mechanical consequences, picking a sin can help you:

  • Shape your character’s backstory (Were they always prideful, or did hardship make them greedy?)
  • Determine how they interact with NPCs (Are they driven by revenge, fear, or personal ambition?)
  • Guide moral choices in the game (Will you help others selflessly, or always expect payment?)

For players who enjoy immersing themselves in the story, the Holy Cedar Tablet can be a great way to add depth to their character.

Should Blizzard Expand the Holy Cedar Tablet’s Impact?

Since Diablo 4 is built around choices and consequences, many players feel that the Holy Cedar Tablet should have a greater impact on the game. Here are some ways Blizzard could expand on this system in the future:

1. Class-Specific Reactions

NPCs could react differently based on your class and sin choice.

  • A Necromancer who confesses to Fear might be treated as an outcast.
  • A Barbarian who confesses to Anger might be encouraged to fight in gladiator pits.
  • A Rogue who chooses Greed might get exclusive mercenary missions.

2. Branching Quests

Your chosen sin could lead to unique questlines, such as:

  • Greed unlocking a treasure hunt quest.
  • Fear opening up a storyline about overcoming past trauma.
  • Anger leading to a revenge mission against a past enemy.

3. Stat or Passive Bonuses

While unlikely, Blizzard could introduce subtle passive effects based on your sin.

  • Pride: Slight bonus to critical hit chance.
  • Fear: Bonus dodge chance when at low health.
  • Anger: Boost to fury or resource regeneration.
  • Greed: Increased gold and loot drop rates.

These wouldn’t break the game but would add more personality to the choice.

Final Thoughts: Does the Holy Cedar Tablet Matter?

Right now, the Holy Cedar Tablet is purely symbolic, serving as a lore-building device rather than a gameplay mechanic. However, it offers a great roleplaying opportunity for players who want to define their character’s motivations.

  • The sin you choose can help shape your class identity, guiding your actions in Sanctuary.
  • It adds depth to the world, reinforcing the oppressive control of the Cathedral of Light.
  • While it doesn’t impact mechanics yet, Blizzard could expand its significance in future updates.

Whether you pick Fear, Anger, Pride, or Greed, the choice is what you make of it. For some, it’s just a bit of flavor text. For others, it’s a defining moment in their D4 items character’s journey.